Is Rental Arbitrage Legal in St. Louis, MO?

A permit system that a court has paused. St. Louis lets owners and authorized tenants apply for a short-term rental permit, with limits on units and multi-unit buildings. A court order on April 22, 2025 stopped the city from taking applications or enforcing the permit requirement, and the current status isn't confirmed here.
Can a renter do rental arbitrage here? Yes. A renter can license a unit they lease, with the permit or license this page describes.
Requirements
- A short-term rental permit, applied for by the owner or an authorized tenant (a natural person)
- Occupied permits: the unit must be the applicant's primary residence
- Non-occupied permits: no residency requirement, up to four units citywide
- No outstanding taxes or other obligations to the city
- Property can't benefit from tax increment financing or tax abatement
Restrictions
- Multi-unit building caps run from 50% (3 to 4 units) down to 12.5% (24 or more units)
- A court order of April 22, 2025 paused applications, permits, inspections and fee collection, and the city said it wouldn't enforce the permit requirement meanwhile
- Fines of $500 per violation, with each day separate, and permit revocation after three violations in 24 months, when the permit system applies
Official permit or registration page
Next Step
Legal is one half of the decision. The other half is whether the deal earns enough to be worth the risk.
Sources
Frequently Asked Questions
- Can a Renter Do Rental Arbitrage in St. Louis?
- Yes, in principle. The ordinance lets an authorized tenant apply for a permit. Occupied permits need the unit to be your primary residence, and non-occupied permits allow up to four units.
- Is the Permit System in Force?
- A court order of April 22, 2025 paused it. The city stopped taking applications and said it wouldn't enforce the permit requirement. Check the city's page for the current status.
- Why Did the Court Pause It?
- A lawsuit argues the $150 annual permit fee works as a hidden tax under the Hancock Amendment. The judge found the plaintiff had a likelihood of success.
- What Caps Apply in Multi-Unit Buildings?
- From 50% in buildings of 3 to 4 units down to 12.5% in buildings of 24 or more.